Sweet and Spicy Mustard — Hatch Chile Store
A jar of Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard on a woven mat, flanked by dried chilies, with a neutral background.
4.9 • 17 Reviews

Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard

Real Hatch chile in glass jars. Shelf-stable for 18–24 months unopened. No freezer space required, no dry ice in transit.

Mix & match savings

Mix any pantry items — jars, salsas, powders, seasonings. The more you add, the less every one of them costs.

  • GoodBuy 310% off
  • BetterBuy 615% off
  • BestBuy 1220% off

No code needed — the discount applies automatically at checkout and covers every eligible item in your cart.

When will my order ship?

Pantry orders ship from our warehouse Monday through Friday. Most go out the same business day.

Order by 2:00 PM MT
Monday – Friday · Same-day shipping
  • Holidays may impact shipping schedules.
  • Tracking info is emailed automatically when your order ships.
  • Need it faster? Choose Overnight shipping at checkout!

All cutoff times are U.S. Mountain Time (MT).
Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard
Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard
Ships by
Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard
Sweet & Spicy Hatch Chile Mustard
  • Real Hatch Chile
  • Bottled in New Mexico
  • Family-Owned Since 1917
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee

Why real chile only grows here

Champagne's got its valley. We have ours.

Minerals you can taste
The Soil

Minerals you can taste

NMSU found 23% more flavor compounds than chile grown anywhere else.

300+ days a year
The Sun

300+ days a year

Desert UV burns flavor deep into every pepper.

100° day. 60° night.
The Swing

100° day. 60° night.

The plant fights harder. The chile gets deeper.

Fed by the Rio Grande
The Water

Fed by the Rio Grande

Elephant Butte runoff. Minerals you can taste in every bite.

The Proof Is in the Chile

4.9 ★★★★★ Based on 17 reviews
100% five-star reviews
Carol R
Verified Buyer
04/11/25
★★★★★ 04/11/25

Our son gave this mustard to us as a gift. We’ll never, ever use any other mustard😋. It’s simply the best!!!!!

Joseph E
Verified Buyer
03/24/25
★★★★★ 03/24/25

This stuff is amazing. Used it on hotdog, sandwich and Chicken tenders took them to a different level.

87419 C
Verified Buyer
03/13/25
★★★★★ 03/13/25

I am one who enjoys a little kick in my mustard this product is just perfect, also went great in my deviled eggs, Yummy good ,

Bruce M
Verified Buyer
01/25/25
★★★★★ 01/25/25

Rosalie E
Verified Buyer
09/28/24
★★★★★ 09/28/24

I love them so much

Eric S
Verified Buyer
11/13/23
★★★★★ 11/13/23

Love it on my Cuban sandwiches, not too spicy but adds tons of flavor to any sandwich

Linda B
Verified Buyer
09/15/23
★★★★★ 09/15/23

Excellent Flavor. I no longer need to buy regular mustard. This is my Go to Mustard.

Daniel G
Verified Buyer
09/09/23
★★★★★ 09/09/23

Very satisfying taste that starts sweet and finishes with a nice kick. Not overly spicy. Use as a substitute for regular mustard where I use mustard. Thanks!

Glenn D
Verified Buyer
08/31/23
★★★★★ 08/31/23

Gave three bottles to my son in law and both of families think it is outstanding. Used it on hamburgers ham pork chops and hot dogs. Really brought out a great taste and made everything taste great. I guess the old yellow mustard is going to take a back seat😀

Michael D
Verified Buyer
06/05/23
★★★★★ 06/05/23

I have tried several things from Hatch Chili and I like them all. I Love this sweet and spicy mustard ! Burgers, dogs, etc. Sausage and onions on a tortilla with this mustard, excellent !

M B
Verified Buyer
06/02/23
★★★★★ 06/02/23

I have lived my entire life on the NC coast, not a fan of mustard OR vinegar, & definitely not spicy food! In my 2 short years in NM, I have become a chile expert (to my beach fan)! This is the only mustard that will ever darken my doorstep again! It’s absolutely DELICIOUS! Running low, only 3 bottles in the pantry! Let me order more now before ...

Customer photo
Dennis O
Verified Buyer
05/23/23
★★★★★ 05/23/23

So much flavor in such a small jar...

Sal S
Verified Buyer
01/02/23
★★★★★ 01/02/23

Great tasting best mustard I ever had

Sal S
Verified Buyer
11/26/22
★★★★★ 11/26/22

Prompt delivery and best mustard I've ever tasted

Dianne K
Verified Buyer
08/30/22
★★★★★ 08/30/22

Great product. Placed my second order when it became available. Love the combination of a slightly sweet and spicy flavor.

Maggie C
Verified Buyer
08/06/22
★★★★★ 08/06/22

This Mustard makes every sandwich, hotdog, hamburger and chicken plate so so good. It is both sweet and spicy tasting that tickles your taste buds. Should always have some in the pantry!

Review photo

Sauces & Salsas FAQs

Same chile, different ripeness. Green chile is harvested before it ripens — bright, vegetal, slightly grassy. Red is the same chile left on the plant to fully ripen — sweeter, deeper, more raisin-like. Both have the same baseline heat for their variety. Red is the traditional choice for tamales and Christmas pork; green is what most people associate with breakfast burritos and Hatch cooking.

Ingredient lists vary by product — check the label on this page. Most of our sauces use only chile, salt, vinegar, garlic, and spices. None of our sauces use artificial colors or flavors.

Most are. A few of our condiments (like specific BBQ sauces) may contain trace gluten — always read the label or contact us if you have a sensitivity. We don't run a dedicated gluten-free facility, so cross-contact is possible.

Medium Hatch chile runs 2,000–7,000 SHU; Big Jim, our most common Medium variety, measures approximately 6,500 SHU per NMSU CR706 (our pods often a touch milder). For reference, jalapeños run 2,500–8,000 SHU, so Medium overlaps jalapeño heat. Our Medium has presence — you'll feel it — but it doesn't overwhelm the dish. It's the heat level most repeat customers order.

Our jarred sauces, salsas, and condiments are produced at our New Mexico facility (Amigo's Mexican Foods, USDA-inspected, family-owned since 1978) or by trusted Hatch Valley partners. Every batch starts with real Hatch chile.

You May Also Like

PRODUCT DESCRIPTION